Cryptocurrency: Security or Commodity?

The question of whether cryptocurrency should be classified as a security or commodity has been a contentious issue in the cryptocurrency space. This question has been debated for years, and it has become increasingly important as regulatory agencies try to define the legal status of cryptocurrencies.

In this article, we will explore the arguments for and against cryptocurrencies being classified as securities or commodities, using information from a recent Cointelegraph article titled “US House Committee Chair Repeatedly Presses SEC Chair: Is Ether a Commodity or a Security?” We will also examine the role of regulatory agencies, such as the SEC, in setting the rules for cryptocurrencies.

What is a Security?

A security is a financial instrument that represents ownership in a company or organization. Securities can take many forms, such as stocks, bonds, and mutual funds. Securities are subject to regulations and laws designed to protect investors from fraud and manipulation.

What is a Commodity?

A commodity is a raw material or primary agricultural product that can be bought and sold, such as oil, gold, or wheat. Commodities are traded on exchanges and are subject to regulations that ensure fair trading practices.

Arguments for Cryptocurrencies as Securities

One argument for classifying cryptocurrencies as securities is that they are often sold through initial coin offerings (ICOs) as a means of raising funds. In an ICO, a company issues a cryptocurrency to investors in exchange for funding. These cryptocurrencies can be seen as securities because they are essentially digital representations of shares in a company.

Another argument for classifying cryptocurrencies as securities is that they often provide investors with a right to share in the profits of the company that issued them. For example, some cryptocurrencies pay dividends to investors based on the profits of the issuing company.

Arguments for Cryptocurrencies as Commodities

One argument for classifying cryptocurrencies as commodities is that they are often used as a means of exchange, much like traditional currencies. Bitcoin, the most well-known cryptocurrency, is often used to purchase goods and services online. This use as a means of exchange is similar to the use of traditional currencies, such as the U.S. dollar or the euro.

Another argument for classifying cryptocurrencies as commodities is that they are not issued by a single entity or organization. Instead, cryptocurrencies are created through a process known as mining, which involves using computational power to solve complex mathematical problems. Because no single entity controls the creation of cryptocurrencies, they can be seen as commodities, similar to gold or oil.

The Role of Regulatory Agencies

The debate over whether cryptocurrencies should be classified as securities or commodities has significant regulatory implications. Regulatory agencies, such as the SEC, have the authority to determine the legal status of cryptocurrencies and to set rules for their trading and use.

However, it is important to note that regulatory agencies do not have the authority to set the rules for cryptocurrencies themselves. Instead, they can only enforce existing laws and regulations. The rules for cryptocurrencies are set by the developers and users of the technology, as well as by the market forces that govern their use and value.

Conclusion

The debate over whether cryptocurrencies should be classified as securities or commodities is an ongoing one, with arguments on both sides. The legal status of cryptocurrencies will likely continue to evolve as regulators grapple with the unique features of this new technology.

Ultimately, the success of cryptocurrencies will depend on their ability to provide value to users and investors, and to navigate the complex legal and regulatory landscape that surrounds them. Whether cryptocurrencies are ultimately classified as securities or commodities, it is clear that they represent a new and disruptive force in the world of finance and commerce.

To learn more about blockchain register for our courses at the BWBC Academy, or become a BWBC Member. Learn the history of blockchain, smart contracts and more at your leisure. You can even earn a certification and learn to build your own smart contract.  The skies the limit with blockchain. Join a growing community of innovators and thought leaders who are shaping the future of technology and the world we live in. So why wait? Sign up today and start your blockchain education journey with us.

For more information on what becoming a BWBC member means check out https://bwbc.io/community/